Order Number |
3245633092 |
Type of Project |
ESSAY |
Writer Level |
PHD VERIFIED |
Format |
APA |
Academic Sources |
10 |
Page Count |
3-12 PAGES |
Just Need Peer Reviews
Peer Review 1
the goal of this assignment is to learn about a new molecular biology tool called CRISPR which scientist say is “A game-changing genetic engineering technique”. To support your contribution to the discussion board:
John
CRISPR stands for “clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats.” It is a way for scientist to alter or edit DNA and modify the genes. Using this process could cure and save many
people by correcting genetic defects, treating and preventing the spread of diseases. CRISPR is derived from CRISPR-Cas9 are parts of the DNA that are capable of cutting strands of DNA.
Having the ability to correct genetic defects could be a life saver for some. This could help cure cystic fibrosis, HIV, cancer and cataracts for example. It could also be used to produce more
yield from crops and their ability to survive in various elements. On the other hand, you are giving humans the ability to change a person DNA. What happens when that person then
reproduces and their changed DNA is inherited by their off spring. Can you mix CRISPR DNA with that of another? There couold be unintended consequences of the changes that are made.
I talked to my daughter, who is studying biology, but has yet to learn about CRISPR. We discussed what the possibilities could be to help save human lives and make thing better. We think
everyone would agree that any tool that could help save people from pain and suffering is a good tool. However, there are cons to what humans create. There is always an opposite and equal
reaction to things in life. If good is trying to be achieved, evil will find a way to utilize it to their advantage. As well, how will future generations adapt to this new editing as offspring is
produced. We will start to modify genetic make-ups of human kind. What will that mix bring? A superhuman? What about mother nature adapting to our creations. Will new diseases and virus
come about? The cat is already out of the bag with CRISPR. We believe scientist must tread lightly with the ability to alter the future of human kind.
Hartwell
One of the two who’d never heard didn’t want to keep listening to the conversation, because she was horrified. It’s notable she was previously a hospital clinician, and said “how do they know
they won’t just cause cancer?” The other who’d just heard seemed to have a tough time digesting it, and before I could finish automatically went to the conclusion that it would be used as a
weapon via the military. I thought this was interesting, because that’s exactly how my mind worked, hence me citing the above article on the military use of CRISPR.
The two who’d already heard of CRISPR – one didn’t really seem to take much of an ethical issue at all, pointing out that science has already been doing experiments on human embryos for a
long time, and that this wasn’t really anything that different. I will say that this person seemed not very well informed though, so I question the validity of the feedback. The other who’d heard
about it, didn’t really give a strong opinion but did highlight that it’s definitely highly controversial.
One thing to keep in mind – we’re all persons in charge of regulatory compliance, and are trained to always think of patient safety. So, I’d consider this definitely a conservative group. That
said, 2/4 disapproved of CRISPR, 1/4 did not see any issue, and 1/4 neither approved nor disapproved. Given these results, I feel a bit more comfortable that my reservations are shared. Or, to
use a regulatory concept – I do not see that the benefits of CRISPR outweigh the risks.
Peer Review 2
Alternative Energy: The sources for and uses of energy are some of the most pressing and influential questions to be answered by industry and science today. The search for alternative fuels
is a major part of this endeavor. Here is an interesting interview with Bill Gates on this topic.